After Stephen Robinson's departure, Aberdeen is on the hunt for a new manager yet again, marking the fifth dismissal since 2021. The club's struggle for consistent results and Scottish Premiership competitiveness has been a recurring theme. Derek McInnes, who delivered results with Rangers after his tenure at Aberdeen, remains the last Pittodrie boss to achieve such success.
Two potential candidates emerging early in the search are Steven Pressley of Dundee and John McGlynn from Falkirk. Both have impressed in the Premiership over the past year and a half, earning admiration for their stylish play and results. Falkirk currently ranks third, two places above Dundee, while McGlynn's side finished sixth last season, again ahead of Pressley's team.
Former Aberdeen defender Richard Foster and ex-Scottish midfielder Michael Stewart have praised both managers for their leadership skills and tactical acumen. Stewart lauds McGlynn's ability to scout talent and his successful recruitment record, while Foster highlights Pressley's quiet yet commanding presence in the dressing room.
Another contender is Steve Clarke, who recently stepped down as Scotland head coach but boasts extensive coaching experience, including in Scotland with Kilmarnock. Clarke has overseen three major tournament qualifications for Scotland and has worked at top English clubs like Chelsea, Liverpool, and Newcastle United. Appointing Clarke would be a significant statement by Aberdeen, offering the challenge of restoring the club to competitiveness. However, personal circumstances may influence whether candidates like McGlynn and Clarke can make the move to the north-east.
Gary Caldwell, Wigan Athletic boss and former Scotland center-half, has also been linked with the Pittodrie job. Caldwell honed his managerial skills with Wigan and returned there this year following stints at Chesterfield, Partick Thistle, and Exeter City. Aberdeen may be looking further afield this time, considering they have mostly stuck to Scottish managers in the past. The club's sporting director, Lutz Pfannenstiel, is German, suggesting a potential shift in recruitment strategy.