In a controversial turn of events at the Premier League, the Key Match Incidents Panel has criticized the decision by video assistant referee Stuart Attwell not to award a penalty to Liverpool's Alexander Isak during their match against Arsenal. The incident occurred in the 21st minute of the game held at Anfield on 1 November, when Jurrien Timber was accused of pulling Isak's shirt as he attempted to reach a cross from Bradley Barcola. Despite the apparent foul, referee Andy Madley did not award a penalty, and the decision was upheld by VAR Stuart Attwell. However, replays revealed the grab, leading the KMI Panel to rule that a penalty should have been given on the field with a 4:1 majority vote. The VAR's inaction was also questioned, with a 3:2 vote suggesting he should have intervened and sent the referee to the pitchside monitor. Arsenal led 1-0 at the time through Kai Havertz, a lead that remained unchanged throughout the game.

Two panelists argued that the "subjectivity in assessing impact" prevented intervention, but the majority view was that it was a "clear and obvious error" by the VAR. One panellist considered the "short-lived holding to lack clear impact on Isak's ability to progress." Post-match, Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola expressed his dissatisfaction, stating that there was a clear shirt grab and that if Isak had fallen, a penalty would have been inevitable. He also suggested that future incidents may require players to "dive" to secure penalties, a comment that has sparked debate in the football community.

In another VAR-related controversy, the KMI Panel ruled that Ipswich should have been awarded a penalty against Hull City on 31 October. Nobel Mendy was accused of holding back Dara O'Shea at a corner, an offence missed by referee Peter Bankes and VAR Neil Davies. The game was scoreless at the time, but Ipswich took the lead shortly afterwards, eventually finishing in a 2-2 draw. This incident has fueled discussions about the effectiveness of VAR in the Premier League.

With two controversial decisions in as many weeks, questions are being raised about the performance of VAR in the English Premier League. Incident-by-incident analysis suggests that it was indeed a bad weekend for the technology.