ESPN analyst Mina Kimes has raised eyebrows with her recent critique of Josh Allen's performance, despite the Buffalo Bills' impressive 8-1 record this season. On The Mina Kimes Show, she argued that Allen is playing worse than last year, a claim that contradicts his MVP-level statistics and the team's success. Despite Allen breaking an NFL record in their recent 31-12 win over the New York Jets, Kimes left him out of the MVP conversation. Allen's completion rate has dipped slightly from last season, but his touchdown pace and rushing numbers suggest a different story. At his current pace, he is on track to surpass or match his 2025 production in most areas. Furthermore, Allen ran for 21 touchdowns this year, setting him up for a potential 20-20 season - a feat that has never been achieved before. On Sunday, Allen also broke Peyton Manning's record for the most total career touchdowns in the first 10 seasons of an NFL career. Despite Kimes' critique, Allen's performance on the field continues to be exceptional, raising questions about the validity of her observations.

---

ESPN analyst Mina Kimes has questioned the progress of Buffalo Bills star quarterback Josh Allen, despite his impressive MVP-level statistics and the team's dominant 8-1 record this season. During a conversation on The Mina Kimes Show about MVP candidates through Week 10 with Ben Solak, Kimes left Allen out of the discussion. She argued that while Allen is asked to do a lot, he is playing worse than last year "to her eyes," but the box score does not support this claim.

Allen won the MVP award in 2024, and the Bills have managed to maintain their strong performance even with key receivers injured and James Cook fumbling. Allen's completion rate has slipped slightly from last season, dropping from 69.3 percent to 65.0 percent through nine games. However, almost everything else points in the opposite direction.

At his current pace, Allen is on track to throw for more yards than in 2025 and match last year's 25 passing touchdowns. He is also on pace for 13 interceptions, three more than last season, but ball security elsewhere has improved, with no fumbles in nine games compared to six last year, two of which were lost.

The rushing numbers are where Allen really stands out. He ran for 14 touchdowns in 2025 and is on pace for 21 this year, with similar yardage. NFL analyst Michael F. Florio wrote on his official account that there has never been a 20-20 season, and Allen's current numbers suggest he could be the first to achieve it. Sunday's game against the New York Jets added to the case, as Allen ran for a touchdown that broke Peyton Manning's record for the most total career touchdowns in the first 10 seasons of an NFL career.

---

On The Mina Kimes Show on Tuesday, ESPN analyst Mina Kimes questioned the progress of Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen despite his impressive MVP-level statistics and the team's dominant 8-1 record this season. Asked about the top MVP candidates, she moved past Allen quickly, stating that he is playing worse than last year "to her eyes." However, the box score does not support this claim, as Allen won the MVP award in 2024 and has maintained strong performance even with key receivers injured and James Cook fumbling.

Allen's completion rate has slipped slightly from last season, dropping from 69.3 percent to 65.0 percent through nine games, but almost everything else points in the opposite direction. At his current pace, Allen is on track to throw for more yards than in 2025 and match last year's 25 passing touchdowns. He is also on pace for 13 interceptions, three more than last season, but ball security elsewhere has improved, with no fumbles in nine games compared to six last year, two of which were lost.

The rushing numbers are where Allen really stands out. He ran for 14 touchdowns in 2025 and is on pace for 21 this year, with similar yardage. NFL analyst Michael F. Florio wrote on his official account that there has never been a 20-20 season, and Allen's current numbers suggest he could be the first to achieve it. Sunday's game against the New York Jets added to the case, as Allen ran for a touchdown that broke Peyton Manning's record for the most total career touchdowns in the first 10 seasons of an NFL career.

---

On Tuesday, ESPN analyst Mina Kimes questioned the progress of Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen despite his impressive MVP-level statistics and the team's dominant 8-1 record this season. During a conversation on The Mina Kimes Show about MVP candidates through Week 10 with Ben Solak, she moved past Allen quickly, stating that he is playing worse than last year "to her eyes." However, the box score does not support this claim, as Allen won the MVP award in 2024 and has maintained strong performance even with key receivers injured and James Cook fumbling.

Allen's completion rate has slipped slightly from last season, dropping from 69.3 percent to 65.0 percent through nine games, but almost everything else points in the opposite direction. At his current pace, Allen is on track to throw for more yards than in 2025 and match last year's 25 passing touchdowns. He is also on pace for 13 interceptions, three more than last season, but ball security elsewhere has improved, with no fumbles in nine games compared to six last year, two of which were lost.

The rushing numbers are where Allen really stands out. He ran for 14 touchdowns in 2025 and is on pace for 21 this year, with similar yardage. NFL analyst Michael F. Florio wrote on his official account that there has never been a 20-20 season, and Allen's current numbers suggest he could be the first to achieve it. Sunday's game against the New York Jets added to the case, as Allen ran for a touchdown that broke Peyton Manning's record for the most total career touchdowns in the first 10 seasons of an NFL career. Despite Kimes' critique, Allen's performance on the field continues to be exceptional, raising questions about the validity of her observations.