Just a few months after being appointed as the head coach of the Scottish national team, Sebastien Pocognoli finds himself under intense scrutiny following Scotland's disappointing 4-0 loss to Switzerland. The defeat has reignited discussions about Pocognoli's future with the team, as many question whether he is the right man for the job. Craig Mulholland, the Scottish FA's chief football officer, and Ian Maxwell, the association's chief executive, had previously praised Pocognoli as their top choice, but the team's poor performance has raised concerns about his coaching abilities.

Pocognoli's system has been criticized for making Scotland a disjointed and soft touch on the field, with players looking lost and structural discipline collapsing too often. In six games under Pocognoli, Scotland has scored only five goals, two of which came from penalties. The team's lackluster performance against Switzerland has been particularly damning, with Andy Robertson, Scotland's most capped player in history, delivering a scathing critique of the coaching regime and the team's overall performance.

Robertson's comments echoed those of John McGinn, who also criticized Pocognoli for failing to deliver results. The players themselves have been accused of not giving their all on the field, with some former Scotland internationals suggesting that they were not busting a gut during the match against Switzerland. This has led to calls for an honesty session between the SFA hierarchy and the senior operators in the team, as well as concerns about the team's ability to qualify for the next Euros, which begins in March.

Pocognoli comes across as a passionate and hard-working coach, but his stubbornness in setting up his team has been exploited by more experienced coaches like Switzerland boss Murat Yakin. Yakin was able to win the game at a canter despite missing several key players, starting six players who had six caps or fewer between them, three of whom scored. The contrast between Pocognoli and former coach Steve Clarke is stark, with Clarke having vast experience and the ability to fix problems, while Pocognoli lacks a track record in turning bad situations into good ones.

Overall, Pocognoli's future as head coach of Scotland is uncertain, with many questioning whether he has what it takes to lead the team to success. The SFA hierarchy will need to carefully consider their options and take steps to address the team's poor performance if they hope to turn things around before the next Euros qualification campaign begins in March.