India's batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the decision to omit Mohammed Siraj from the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand, despite criticism following a challenging opening day for India's bowling attack at Wellington's Basin Reserve on Thursday. With Jasprit Bumrah dominating, other pace options faltered as New Zealand recovered from 70/5 to end the day on 243/5, thanks to an unbroken 173-run sixth-wicket stand between Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips. Anshul Kamboj, standing in for Siraj, managed only one wicket for 57 runs, while Prasidh Krishna and Akash Deep conceded 58 and 33 runs respectively. Bumrah finished with impressive figures of 3/52 from 17 overs.

Kotak clarified the reasons behind Siraj's omission, stating that the team management had taken into account the conditions and opposition when selecting their best XI. He also explained the rationale behind India's bowling combination, highlighting the varying skills within the pace attack and the inclusion of Washington Sundar due to New Zealand's four left-handed batsmen.

However, the decision to leave out Siraj drew scrutiny as Bumrah consistently troubled the New Zealand batters while other Indian bowlers struggled to maintain pressure after the new ball lost its shine. Prasidh Krishna's expensive spell included several boundary balls, but Kotak defended him as an attacking bowler who can occasionally go for runs in pursuit of wickets.

India had made a strong start after winning the toss, with Bumrah dismissing Tom Latham, Devon Conway, Daryl Mitchell, and Tom Blundell to leave New Zealand reeling at 70/5. Kamboj also contributed an early wicket, but Nicholls and Phillips turned the tide with a patient yet assertive partnership. Kotak acknowledged that India missed opportunities to make further inroads, particularly when Rishabh Pant failed to catch Nicholls, who eventually reached his 12th Test century. As the day ended, India found themselves grappling with a revitalized New Zealand side and questions about their bowling lineup.